The world's best way to find live classical music

Find reviews of Symphony no. 5 in C sharp minor

Date and venueTitleSubmitted by
22-May-2013
La Maison Symphonique de Montréal
Mahler's Fifth with David Zinman and the Orchestre Symphonique de MontréalAndrew Crust
Image credit: David Zinman © Priska KettererThe program this evening was quite significantly lopsided – though most programs containing Mahler symphonies end up being this way. Tonight’s juxtaposition was quite profound, perhaps even more than usual. Mozart’s Piano Concerto no. 18 in B flat major was poised like a pebble next to a mountain. It was a polished pebble, but minuscule in comparison nonetheless.
Read full review...
24-Feb-2013
Birmingham Symphony Hall
Hands-down winners: CBSO Youth Orchestra and Bavouzet triumph in Mahler and RavelKatherine Dixson, katherinedixson.co.uk
Image credit: Jean-Efflam Bavouzet © Paul MitchellJudging by this evening’s performance, the future of music-making in Birmingham is in safe hands. Following an intensive half-term week’s training, including sectional coaching by musicians from the parent orchestra, 100 eager and accomplished 14- to 21-year-olds brought the Symphony Hall stage to life.
Read full review...
24-Feb-2013
Colston Hall
Sublime Mahler and Penderecki: The Polish National Radio Symphony Orchestra in BristolAlexandra Hamilton-Ayres
Image credit: Jacek Kaspszyk © Sophie WrightWhat a concert – the programme and the musicans were sublime. This time, Colston Hall got it spot on with the Polish National Radio Symphony Orchestra. Seeing all of the credits for the orchestra in the back of the programme prepared me for a big and bold sound that was just short of 100 musicians. Each and every one of them contributed to a fantastic sound under the baton of Jacek Kaspszyk.
Read full review...
12-Dec-2012
Southbank Centre: Royal Festival Hall
Jurowski's endgame: Grisey and Mahler with the LPONinfea Cruttwell-Reade
Image credit: The London Philharmonic Orchestra in the Royal Festival Hall © Richard CannonThe London Philharmonic Orchestra’s latest “only connect” programme was inspired by its allocated date – 12/12/12. An equivalent numerical repetition will not recur for another century. Furthermore the reversal of the first figure to 21 coincides with the day signalled by the Mayan calendar as a day of ending. In keeping with this apocalyptic vantage point, Gérard Grisey’s Quatre chants pour franchir le seuil (“Four Chants for Crossing the Threshold”, 1996–98) and Gustav Mahler’s Symphony no. 5 (1901–02) were paired to map a journey from the dark abyss into a bright awakening.
Read full review...
22-Nov-2012
Auckland Town Hall
Magnificent Messiaen and Mahler from the Auckland PhilharmoniaSimon Holden
Image credit: Eckehard StierAuckland is a good place to be for Mahler lovers at the moment. Following hard on the heels of the New Zealand Symphony Orchestra’s Seventh Symphony, the Auckland Philharmonia brought their interpretation of his Fifth to the same hall. Despite being in five movements, Mahler also designated the work as being in three parts; the first and second movements making up Part One, the long third movement making up Part Two and the fourth and fifth movements making up Part Three.
Read full review...
9-Nov-2012
Hong Kong Cultural Centre: Concert Hall
Lou Harrison, Henry Cowell and a well-honed Mahler 5 with the San Francisco Symphony in Hong KongAlan Yu, alanayu.wordpress.com
Image credit: Michael Tilson ThomasFaced with ageing audiences, dwindling funding and slashed budgets, many fine orchestras feel besieged at home these days, let alone being able to embark on costly tours overseas – all the more reason why the San Francisco Symphony’s ambitious tour of six cities in Asia is a cause for celebration. The orchestra’s decision to include works by American composers who draw their inspiration from this part of the world is a masterstroke of cultural diplomacy.
Read full review...
12-Oct-2012
Bridgewater Hall
BBC Philharmonic and Juanjo Mena: Mozart and MahlerRohan Shotton
Image credit: Juanjo Mena © CAMIIt must be a strange feeling, sitting down to play a short work while surrounded by empty chairs waiting for a big second half symphony. Tonight Steven Osborne and the modest proportions of Mozart’s orchestra were given the task of invigorating the Piano Concerto no. 19 and avoiding an almost inevitable feeling of it being a pre-Mahler apéritif.
Read full review...
26-Aug-2012
Usher Hall
Budapest Festival Orchestra in triumphant Bartók and MahlerJeremy Morris
Image credit: Budapest Festival OrchestraThe Budapest Festival Orchestra has played in Edinburgh before to great critical acclaim. Consequently, it was only to be expected that their concert last Sunday would be well attended, despite a late change of soloist. In fact, it was a virtual sell-out and we were not disappointed.
Read full review...
17-May-2012
Southbank Centre: Royal Festival Hall
A Magnificent Mahler 5 from Daniele Gatti and the PhilharmoniaDavid Allen, unpredictableinevitability.com
Image credit: Daniele Gatti © Marco Dos DantosYou can, more often than not, tell how good a performance of Mahler's Fifth will be from its opening trumpet call. Here, the Philharmonia's principal, Alistair Mackie, struck just the right balance between stridency and tragedy. Daniele Gatti's direction of this symphony was not, however, one of balance, still less one of compromise. London audiences have heard a lot of Mahler over the last two or three years, but this performance was surely one of the greatest.
Read full review...
2-Dec-2011
Hong Kong Cultural Centre: Concert Hall
The Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra play Mozart and MahlerAlan Yu, alanayu.wordpress.com
Image credit: Osmo Vänskä, © Greg HelgesonI went to the concert with the Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra on Friday with some pre-conceived ideas about how they should play the two works on the programme, and came away satisfied that the performance more than met expectations. Having heard Mozart's Piano Concerto no. 23 in A many times, played by masters of the instrument – Anda, Ashkenazy, Barenboim, Brendel, Horowitz and Kempff, to name but a few – I had high expectations for the soloist for the evening, Paul Lewis.
Read full review...
5-May-2011
Southbank Centre: Royal Festival Hall
Man's music?Andrew Benson-Wilson
The songs of Des Knaben Wunderhorn ("The Youth’s Magic Horn") form the basis for so much of Mahler’s music that it pays to hear some of them alongside a symphony (in the case the well-known Fifth Symphony, in the latest of the Philharmonia/Maazel collaborations). The performances of six of the songs by Sarah Connolly and Matthias Goerne gave a clear idea of the emotional power that they contain.
Read full review...
7-Apr-2011
Philharmonie: Großer Saal
Purcell and Mahler at the Berlin PhilharmonieDavid Karlin
Image credit: RIAS Kammerchor © Matthias HeydeLast night was my first ever visit to the Berlin Philharmonie, and it couldn't have been more eagerly awaited: if you'd asked me to name the work I most wanted to see here, it would have been Rattle conducting the Berliner Philharmoniker in Mahler 5. But I settled into my seat with slight trepidation: after all that anticipation, what would I write if it wasn't up to standard?
Read full review...
26-Sep-2010
Barbican Centre: Hall
LSO's Pitch Perfect MahlerHannah Gill
Image credit: Matt StuartIn the second Lord Mayor’s concert held at the Barbican this weekend, the 2010 appeal called for donations for a new initiative called ‘Pitch Perfect.’ This scheme provides opportunities to take part in music and cricket for children in the most deprived East London boroughs, where the LSO is widely involved in community projects. Music, like sport, encourages participation, and there can be no greater advocate for teamwork than the tightly knit LSO, which, even as its forces swelled to take on the Mahler, lost none of its precision and clarity.
Read full review...
23-Sep-2010
Colston Hall
Death and Spain at the Colston HallKemal Yusuf
Image credit: Alberto VenzagoAs part of this year’s classical season, the London Symphony Orchestra returns to the Colston Hall. Last year they were lead by John Adams, taking us into his explosive Dr Atomic Symphony. This time the world famous orchestra was led by its celebrated principal conductor Valery Gergiev, winner of the prestigious 2009 Royal Philharmonic Society Award for his ‘intensity and passion ... a conductor who makes things happen’ .
Read full review...
5-Aug-2010
Royal Albert Hall
Prom 26: Valery Gergiev conducts the World Orchestra for PeaceSimon Birch
If there were to be one orchestra that is essentially a “dream team”, the World Orchestra for Peace would surely be it. Comprising of almost 100 elite players from 33 different countries, the majority of whom hold principle positions in their respective orchestras, I couldn’t help but be excited by the prospect of seeing such a 300-spartans-like ensemble for the first time, under the mighty command of Valery Gergiev.
Read full review...

bachtracklogo

You can see a list of our reviewers here
Any comments about the site? Send us a message using contact us.
To list events on this site (free of charge) or to learn about advertising with us, please click here.
If you like the site and have a relevant website of your own, we'd love you to link to us.