The world's best way to find live classical music

Reviews by Rohan Shotton

Rohan is a conductor, percussionist and pianist at the University of St Andrews, where he studies Medicine. He has performed a wide variety of music but particularly enjoys music of the late Romantic period.
Date and venueTitle
9-May-2013
Bridgewater Hall
The Rite of Spring with the BBC Philharmonic and Juanjo Mena
Image credit: BBC Philharmonic © BBC Philharmonic / Sussie AhlburgJuanjo Mena concluded his season-long exploration of Stravinsky ballets with a sharp account of the most famous, The Rite of Spring, as part of a programme of unusually grand proportions.
Read full review...
24-Apr-2013
Bridgewater Hall
Budapest Festival Orchestra and Iván Fischer play Beethoven and Brahms in Manchester
Image credit: Budapest Festival OrchestraIván Fischer conducted the Budapest Festival Orchestra in impassioned performances of Dohnányi, Beethoven and Brahms to an appreciative, if criminally small, audience in Manchester. More than any other Music Director one could think of, Fischer has a large claim to the BFO being his orchestra. Since founding the orchestra in 1983, he has been its only chief and has guided it to wide acclaim. Many would question the value of orchestra league tables, but it must say something that such a youthful enterprise made its way to ninth in the world in one such table a couple of years ago.
Read full review...
20-Apr-2013
Royal Northern College of Music
Manchester Camerata at the RNCM
Image credit: Gabor Takacs-Nagy and Manchester Camerata © Jonathan KeenanManchester Camerata’s series of Mozart concertos, an ongoing theme in their 40th anniversary season, came to a close with pianist Ferenc Rados joining fellow Hungarian Gábor Takács-Nagy for a superb account of the Piano Concerto no. 15 at the Royal Northern College of Music.
Read full review...
13-Apr-2013
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Sir Mark Elder: Mahler and the Military Symphony
Image credit: Angelika Kirchschlager © Nikolaus KarlinskyAt the end of a successful week in which the orchestra’s recording of The Apostles won BBC Music Magazine’s Disc of the Year award, Sir Mark Elder conducted the Hallé in a joyfully youthful account of Mahler’s Des Knaben Wunderhorn, followed by graphic Janáček and Hadyn.
Read full review...
28-Mar-2013
Bridgewater Hall
Hunting music in Manchester with the Hallé
Image credit: Sir Mark Elder © Simon DoddSir Mark Elder conducted the Hallé in an unusual programme of music themed around hunting. There were many excellent performances, most memorably in Britten's Our Hunting Fathers, which added substantial depth to the evening.
Read full review...
26-Mar-2013
Birmingham Symphony Hall
An exuberant Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester in Birmingham with Andsnes and Blomstedt
Image credit: Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester © Cosimo FilippiniHerbert Blomstedt brought the Gustav Mahler Jugendorchester to Birmingham for the ninth of their eleven-concert, two-week Easter tour. Their magisterial account of Bruckner’s Romantic Symphony, and a fine performance of Beethoven’s Fourth Piano Concerto by Leif Ove Andsnes, earned them a vociferous reception. A detour to Birmingham between Interlaken and Aix-en-Provence may not seem entirely logical, but the orchestra, made up of European conservatoire students aged 18–26, very visibly enjoyed themselves.
Read full review...
21-Mar-2013
Bridgewater Hall
A 4th and a 104th symphony with the Hallé and Sir Mark Elder
Image credit: Sir Mark Elder © Simon DoddsSir Mark Elder conducted the Hallé in fine performances of Haydn’s final symphony, no. 104, and Mahler’s most humble, no. 4.
Read full review...
20-Mar-2013
Birmingham Symphony Hall
Heart-on-sleeve Beethoven from Andris Nelsons and the CBSO
Image credit: Andris Nelsons © Marco BorggreveAndris Nelsons continued his Beethoven cycle with deeply personal and thrilling accounts of the Sixth and Seventh Symphonies to a sold-out Symphony Hall.
Read full review...
16-Mar-2013
Birmingham Symphony Hall
CBSO and Andris Nelsons: The Flying Dutchman in concert
Image credit: Andris Nelsons conducting the CBSO © © Neil PughAndris Nelsons followed up his 2012 Tristan und Isolde with a stirring performance of Wagner’s breakthrough work, Der fliegende Holländer, with a fine array of soloists and the CBSO in Birmingham.
Read full review...
15-Feb-2013
Bridgewater Hall
Beethoven, Mozart and Schubert from the BBC Philharmonic
Image credit: Juanjo Mena © Sussie Ahlburg, BBC PhilharmonicChief conductor Juanjo Mena conducted a programme of energetic Beethoven and Schubert alongside an original reading of the Mozart Clarinet Concerto at Manchester’s Bridgewater Hall.
Read full review...
10-Feb-2013
Bridgewater Hall
A glowing Meistersinger in Manchester
Image credit: The first violins of the HalléFew things could unite such a large group of people as the Hallé’s Meistersinger did tonight. Some 515 performers, drawn from three orchestras and five choirs, gathered to present highlights from the first two acts of Wagner’s opera and the third act in full. The whole evening was carried off with great warmth, and the roar that answered the last notes was more suggestive of a football match than an opera.
Read full review...
17-Jan-2013
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and André de Ridder: Beethoven, Ligeti and Brahms
Image credit: André de Ridder © Marco BorggreveHaving previously been Assistant Conductor at The Hallé, André de Ridder returned to a bitterly cold Manchester to conduct a fascinating programme, culminating a beautifully autumnal account of Brahms’ Symphony no.4.
Read full review...
9-Jan-2013
Birmingham Symphony Hall
CBSO and Andris Nelsons: Beethoven 4 and 5
Image credit: © Neil PughAndris Nelsons passed the halfway stage of his Birmingham Beethoven cycle with brilliantly muscular accounts of the Fourth and Fifth Symphonies and a glossy performance of the concert aria Ah! Perfido.
Read full review...
13-Dec-2012
Birmingham Symphony Hall
CBSO and Andris Nelsons: Beethoven 3 and Triple Concerto
Image credit: Andris Nelsons © Marco BorggreveAndris Nelsons marked the second instalment in the Birmingham Beethoven cycle with two works of the earliest years of the 19th century, featuring a solid account of the Eroica and a superb performance of the Triple Concerto.
Read full review...
5-Dec-2012
Philharmonic Hall
Mixed Russian music from the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic and Pablo Gonzalez
Image credit: Pablo Gonzales © D. VassSpaniard Pablo Gonzalez made his second appearance with the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic in an all-Russian programme of mixed success, pairing a slightly routine Rachmaninov Second Piano Concerto with a thrilling account of Rimsky-Korsakov’s Scheherazade.
Read full review...
25-Nov-2012
Barbican Centre: Hall
LSO with Semyon Bychkov and Leonidas Kavakos play Berg and Mahler
Image credit: Leonidas Kavakos © Decca/Daniel ReganLast season Semyon Bychkov conducted the LSO in an “outstanding” performance of Mahler’s Third Symphony. This year he returned to conduct the First, the “Titan”, achieving similar success in a magnificent performance which radiated youthful zeal.
Read full review...
16-Nov-2012
Bridgewater Hall
BBC Philharmonic and Juanjo Mena: Bach and Bruckner 9
Image credit: Juanjo Mena © BBC Philharmonic / Sussie AhlburgFew concert programmes can feature such different works based on the same inspiration, but the BBC Philharmonic managed the intricacies of Bach and the grandeur of Bruckner with great success. The biggest tragedy of the evening was the audience: the whole top tier of seating was closed, and the stalls were barely half full.
Read full review...
2-Nov-2012
Bridgewater Hall
Harry Christophers and The Sixteen: Brahms in Manchester
Image credit: Harry Christophers © Marco BorggreveHarry Christophers brought his Sixteen to Manchester for a night of deeply romantic choral music at The Bridgewater Hall. Brahms’ Deutsches Requiem was a foreseeable success, but the seldom-heard Vocal Quartets, settings of Sternau, Schiller, Daumer and Goethe, were a delightful addition to the programme.
Read full review...
25-Oct-2012
Birmingham Symphony Hall
Shostakovich and Rachmaninov with Chailly and the Gewandhaus Orchestra Leipzig
Image credit: Riccardo Chailly © CAMIArguably the highest-profile visiting orchestra of the season, Riccardo Chailly brought his Leipzig orchestra to Birmingham for a duo of 20th-century Russian works. The large audience was not disappointed, Rachmaninov’s second symphony in particular shining in a magnificent performance.
Read full review...
24-Oct-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Markus Stenz: Dvořák and Beethoven
Image credit: Markus Stenz © Catrin MoritzMarkus Stenz conducted a lean and crisp performance of Beethoven’s Eroica Symphony which remained unsentimental and lively throughout, prefaced by a nostalgically sunny Dvořák Cello Concerto with soloist Miklós Perényi.
Read full review...
23-Oct-2012
Bridgewater Hall
Michael Sanderling and the Dresden Philharmonic in Manchester
Image credit: Michael Sanderling © Marco BorggreveThe Dresden Philharmonic brought classy Brahms, Barber and Dvořák to Manchester as part of their UK tour in a forward-looking programme of musical new beginnings. If incisive thrust was occasionally lacking, they more than compensated with elegance all evening.
Read full review...
18-Oct-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Markus Stenz with Wagner and Bruckner
Image credit: Markus Stenz © Catrin MoritzPrincipal Guest Conductor Markus Stenz joined the Hallé for a programme of richly romantic music in nature and name, from the impassioned chromaticism of Tristan and Isolde to the peaks and valleys of Bruckner. Stenz seemed to shirk away from easy heroism all evening, opting instead for softer and harder-won resolution.
Read full review...
14-Oct-2012
Birmingham Symphony Hall
Academy of St Martin in the Fields and Joshua Bell in Birmingham
Image credit: Joshua Bell © Bill PhelpsThough often played with far greater forces, the Beethoven and Mendelssohn played in this concert were well suited to the small size and immediacy of the Academy of St Martin in the Fields. Directed energetically from the leader’s chair by Joshua Bell, they gave crisp and clear performances which highlighted the chamber-style aspects of these works.
Read full review...
12-Oct-2012
Bridgewater Hall
BBC Philharmonic and Juanjo Mena: Mozart and Mahler
Image credit: Juanjo Mena © CAMIIt must be a strange feeling, sitting down to play a short work while surrounded by empty chairs waiting for a big second half symphony. Tonight Steven Osborne and the modest proportions of Mozart’s orchestra were given the task of invigorating the Piano Concerto no. 19 and avoiding an almost inevitable feeling of it being a pre-Mahler apéritif.
Read full review...
11-Oct-2012
Stavanger Concert Hall
Opening night at Stavanger's new Concert Hall
Image credit: Stavanger Symphony Orchestra rehearsing in their new hall, © Jan Inge HagaWhile several of the world’s orchestras are struggling to pay their players, never mind expand, Stavanger has just built a new £100 million concert hall, its interior a triumph of acoustic engineering and its public side with airy atriums and bars looking across attractive bays. This celebratory concert to mark the Konserthus’ opening was heavily packed and warmly received.
Read full review...
29-Sep-2012
Bridgewater Hall
BBC Philharmonic and Juanjo Mena: Wagner Evening
Image credit: BBC Philharmonic at MediaCityUK Salford Quays © BBC / Sussie AhlburgJuanjo Mena launched the BBC Philharmonic’s season with an all-Wagner programme which, despite some small faults, featured some excellent playing.
Read full review...
27-Sep-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Mark Elder: Stravinsky, Shostakovich and Holst
Image credit: Sir Mark Elder © Sheila RockA packed hall, including several primary schools and a handful of mayors, attended for a 20th-century triptych. One suspected that most were there for Holst’s The Planets, but it was the first half’s Stravinsky and Shostakovich which were most revelatory tonight.
Read full review...
19-Sep-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé's season opener: Introverted Brahms and Sibelius
Image credit: Sunwook Kim © Tae-Uk KangSir Mark Elder opened The Hallé’s 2012-13 season with two large works whose darker and more introverted aspects were highlighted very effectively. A disappointingly small audience turned out (the hall was perhaps half full) but the music was very much full and energised.
Read full review...
15-Sep-2012
Birmingham Symphony Hall
CBSO and Andris Nelsons: Metamorphosen and Mahler 2
Image credit: The CBSO conducted by Andris Nelsons © Neil PughPairing Richard Strauss’ Metamorphosen with Mahler’s mighty Resurrection Symphony made for an emotionally exhausting season opener in Birmingham, taking a packed Symphony Hall from anguished lamentation to fist-clenched fury and, ultimately, shattering resolution.
Read full review...
2-Sep-2012
Royal Albert Hall
Prom 69: Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra and Riccardo Chailly play Messiaen and Mahler
Image credit: Riccardo Chailly conducts the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra at the BBC Proms © BBC / Chris ChristodoulouTwo fine concerts from Riccardo Chailly’s Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra filled part of the space between end-of-season Proms from the Berlin and Vienna Philharmonics. They brought Mendelssohn of refinement and poise to Prom 67 and dark, fateful thrust in Messiaen and Mahler for Prom 69.
Read full review...
27-Jul-2012
Royal Albert Hall
Prom 18: Beethoven's Ninth
Image credit: Daniel Barenboim and Michael Barenboim, leader of the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra with soloists (L-R) Anna Samuil, Waltraud Meier, Michael König, René Pape at the BBC Proms © BBC / Chris ChristodoulouFew conductors could hold an audience's applause whilst shaking hands with every member of the orchestra and then speaking extensively about politics. Daniel Barenboim, though, on completion of a week-long Beethoven cycle, did so and then dashed to the Olympic opening ceremony to bear the Olympic flag alongside Ban Ki-Moon, among others. Some critics have written in the last week that no amount of sociopolitical benevolence can paper over minor technical flaws in the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra's playing.
Read full review...
21-Jul-2012
Royal Albert Hall
Prom 10: Barenboim, Beethoven and Boulez, part two
Image credit: Daniel Barenboim conducts the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra in Beethoven’s Symphony no. 1 at the BBC Proms © BBC / Chris ChristodoulouProgramming works by Pierre Boulez alongside a high-profile Beethoven symphony cycle is an easy way to give exposure to the strikingly modern works of the Frenchman, but on seeing a substantial chunk of the audience disappear for an early drink before tonight's Boulez, I wondered if the Beethoven was perhaps too reliable a foil, leaving people little incentive to stay. This was a great pity, as Dialogue de l'ombre double created an amazing atmosphere in the hall and was an excellent inclusion in the programme.
Read full review...
23-Jun-2012
Southbank Centre: Royal Festival Hall
Dudamel and the Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra of Venezuela in London
Image credit: Simón Bolívar Youth Orchestra at the Royal Festival Hall in 2009 © Nohely OliverosThree separate standing ovations answered the first concert of the Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra's London residency, in which they played Beethoven and Britten with all of their trademark joie de vivre and panache. There was more, though; they played at times with a remarkable delicacy considering their uncommonly large forces, and the Britten in particular showed the individual quality of various players.
Read full review...
16-Jun-2012
Birmingham Symphony Hall
Simon Rattle and the Vienna Philharmonic: Brahms, Webern and Schumann
Image credit: Simon Rattle © Mat Hennek EMI ClassicsSimon Rattle returned to Birmingham's Symphony Hall, a construction of his own initiation and the home of his successes with the CBSO, to conduct the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra in a concert as part of the hall's 21st birthday celebrations. He arrived on stage to the kind of reception usually reserved for the end of a concert and masterfully led a rich and intriguing programme of Brahms, Webern and Schumann.
Read full review...
15-Jun-2012
St David's Hall
BBC National Orchestra of Wales and Thierry Fischer: Strauss' Alpine Symphony
Image credit: Thierry Fischer © Chris StockA lengthy standing ovation followed Thierry Fischer’s final St David’s Hall concert with the BBC National Orchestra of Wales, concluding his sixth season with Richard Strauss’ monumental Alpine Symphony after a refined performance of Mozart’s Piano Concerto no. 22 with pianist Angela Hewitt.
Read full review...
24-May-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Nikolaj Znaider: Ninth Symphonies of Beethoven and Shostakovich
Image credit: Nikolaj Znaider © George LangeNikolaj Znaider concluded the Hallé Beethoven cycle in emphatic fashion, preceding the Choral Symphony with another ninth symphony, that of Shostakovich. The football-style roar from the sell-out audience at the end of the evening was a good indicator of the quality of the concert.
Read full review...
1-Apr-2012
Bridgewater Hall
Yuri Temirkanov and the St. Petersburg Philharmonic in Manchester
Image credit: Yuri TemirkanovManchester was very fortunate this week to host three fine orchestras: the Orchestre Nationale du Capitole de Toulouse did a wonderful job of Berlioz on Tuesday and the CBSO gave a towering Sibelius 2 on Thursday. Tonight, the St. Petersburg Philharmonic played a breathtaking concert to a packed hall in the final performance of their UK tour.
Read full review...
15-Mar-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé Perform Strauss, Holst and Elgar
Image credit: Sir Mark Elder, © Simon DoddThis was a moving evening of relatively underrated, large-scale late romantic music, moving from Strauss’ youthful charm to the wistful eloquence of the mature Elgar.
Read full review...
8-Mar-2012
Bridgewater Hall
Leipzig Gewandhaus & St Thomas Choir: St Matthew Passion
Image credit: Members of the St Thomas Choir, © Gert MothesPart of the St Thomas Choir Leipzig’s 800th anniversary celebrations, this Manchester concert was a deeply moving evening in which superb musicianship all round seemed almost to bring Bach himself, a Thomaskantor (choir director) in his day, to the Bridgewater Hall.
Read full review...
1-Mar-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Edward Gardner: Beethoven 8
Image credit: Edward Gardner, © Jillian Edelstein, Camera Press, LondonBy far the smallest audience yet for the Hallé’s Beethoven Symphonies cycle gathered for this eighth instalment, conducted by Edward Gardner, and the absentees missed an evening of supreme charm and playfulness.
Read full review...
9-Feb-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Sir Mark Elder: Beethoven 7
Image credit: Nikolaj Znaider, © George LangeMark Elder finished his part in the Hallé’s Beethoven cycle with a rambunctious performance of the seventh symphony, with works by Sibelius and Bartók adding to a dynamic evening of music. Before conducting Sibelius’ tone poem The Bard, Elder paid tribute to the late Paavo Berglund, the great Finnish conductor and champion of all things Sibelian, who died last month.
Read full review...
19-Jan-2012
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Sir Mark Elder: Beethoven 6
Image credit: Mark Elder, © Simon DoddThe Pastoral Symphony is perhaps an optimistic choice for January in Manchester, but for a short while all memory of the deluge outside evaporated in the Bridgewater Hall. Olivier Messiaen’s suite L’Ascension opened the concert with serene, otherworldly modality in a masterfully sculpted brass chorale. The horn section, unusually, played the first half of the concert seated with the rest of the brass section stage left, which made for tight ensemble and a pure, focused sound, always well intoned and led by brilliant trumpet playing. The dissonances of Messiaen’s distinctive idiom were embraced throughout; never grotesque, but elusive and ethereal, well judged in balance and pacing by conductor Sir Mark Elder.
Read full review...
11-Jan-2012
Birmingham Symphony Hall
Pappano's triumphant Royal Opera House Meistersinger in Birmingham
Image credit: Antonio PappanoThe classical world came off lightly in the recent New Year Honours list, with the Royal Opera House’s knighted Antonio Pappano the only winner. He has much to celebrate, more so after directing last night’s concert performance of Wagner’s Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg with authoritative ease and good cheer, supported by a fine array of soloists.
Read full review...
1-Dec-2011
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Lothar Koenigs: Beethoven 5
Image credit: Garrick Ohlsson, © Paul BodyContinuing their season-long Beethoven cycle, the Hallé programmed the Fifth Symphony with a neo-romantic piano concerto by Samuel Barber and Wagner’s Siegfried Idyll, forming an eclectic mix of works to which orchestra and conductor responded very well.
Read full review...
17-Nov-2011
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Sir Mark Elder: Beethoven Symphony no.4
Image credit: Mark Elder, © Simon DoddContinuing the Hallé’s project of juxtaposing Beethoven symphonies with modern works, the underrated fourth symphony was flanked by works by Helen Grime and Igor Stravinsky, with an intriguingly placed Bach Suite closing the concert.
Read full review...
9-Nov-2011
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé, Elder and Gourlay perform Vaughan Williams, Dvořák and Elgar
Image credit: Andrew GourlayIn an unusual piece of programming by today’s standards, this evening’s symphony, Vaughan Williams’ fifth, was played before the interval, with the lighter works, Dvořák’s Wind Serenade and Elgar’s Cockaigne, later in the evening. Perhaps this brought freshness to the music, for there was a supple versatility in the Hallé’s symphony, darting between the heroic, pastoral and folky elements of the piece with exquisite sensitivity to each.
Read full review...
5-Nov-2011
Bridgewater Hall
The Hallé and Sir Mark Elder: Beethoven 3
Image credit: ©Sheila RockJohn Adams’s Harmonium accompanied the third instalment in the Hallé Beethoven cycle to form an exciting programme of music united by being very radical in its time.
Read full review...
29-Oct-2011
Bridgewater Hall
BBC Philharmonic Orchestra and Pablo Heras-Casado: First Symphonies
Image credit: Pablo Heras-Casado © David Martin PageThe performance of four symphonies in one evening is a rare occurrence, and an interesting feat of programming. The BBC Philharmonic explored the development of the symphonic form from the succint, formal classicism of Haydn and Mozart to the broad romanticism of Brahms, via Prokofiev’s witty take on the classical form.
Read full review...
27-Oct-2011
Bridgewater Hall
Hallé and Marcus Stenz: Beethoven 2
Image credit: Kolja Blacher © Priska KettererThe second instalment in The Hallé Beethoven cycle was led by Principal Guest Conductor Marcus Stenz, and also featured the striking Nordic colours of Jean Sibelius and Magnus Lindberg.
Read full review...
18-Oct-2011
Bridgewater Hall
Moscow Philharmonic and Yuri Simonov: Mussorgsky and Rachmaninov in Manchester
Image credit: The Moscow Philharmonic Orchestra enjoyed an evening of youthful exuberance in the Bridgewater Hall with an all-Russian programme, conducted with grace and refinement by Yuri Simonov. Modest Mussorgsky’s Night on the Bare Mountain explicitly paints what the composer called “Spirits of darkness...and the Black Mass” in a progressively wild orgy before the bells of dawn break the scene. Simonov opted for a generally slow but quite variable tempo through the majority of the piece, in contrast to the common tendency to push for a firmly brisk pace in many readings. This was an interesting adjustment, removing any risk of seeming formulaic with such a popular piece, but added little to the sense of untamed nature. It did make some of the themes suggest folk music, particularly in the oboe/bassoon duet passages. The orchestral playing was as passionate as could be expected: plenty of brassy bite and roars from the percussion section. The dawn passage gave the string section its first opportunity of the evening to display its wonderful sound; rich and full in tone, filling the large hall without straining.
Read full review...
More...

bachtracklogo

You can see a list of our reviewers here
Any comments about the site? Send us a message using contact us.
To list events on this site (free of charge) or to learn about advertising with us, please click here.
If you like the site and have a relevant website of your own, we'd love you to link to us.